8 Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Dayton, OH


Are you a car owner in Dayton, OH wondering where to get the best car insurance? Look no further! We’ve done the research and compiled a list of the 8 best local car insurance agencies in Dayton, OH. With a variety of options ranging from national brands to local independent agencies, you can find the right insurance provider for your needs. Read on to learn more about the top 8 car insurance agencies in Dayton, OH.

Walter A. McFall & Son Agency, Inc.

Established in 1936, Walter A. McFall & Son Agency, Inc. has been catering to the insurance needs of Dayton and its surrounding communities for more than 8 decades. This family-owned multi-line insurance services company provides auto insurance policies to private car owners, motorists, passengers, and commercial vehicle drivers to protect them from risks on the road. Their independent insurance agents are experienced in working with multiple providers to offer basic coverage options such as liability, collision, comprehensive, and medical payments. In addition, they assist policyholders in filing claims for damages due to theft, vandalism, road accidents, and natural disasters. At Walter A. McFall & Son Agency, Inc., they believe in creating long-term relationships with their clients.

Rating: 4.6

Website : https://mcfallinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 937-461-2246

Full Address: 115 Linwood St, Dayton, OH 45405

Get Directions

Community Shirley Insurance

For over 10 years, Community-Shirley Insurance, LLC has been providing the Dayton metro and its surrounding areas with comprehensive insurance services. As an independent agency, the company can shop around with numerous carriers to find the auto insurance policy that best fits the needs of car owners, motorists, and vehicle operators. This includes coverage options such as collision, comprehensive, bodily injury liability, property damage liability, and uninsured motorist protection. In addition, Community-Shirley Insurance, LLC also offers motorcycle, RV, and watercraft insurance packages.

Rating: 4.6

Website : http://communityshirleyinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 937-898-3434

Full Address: 7801 N Dixie Dr, Dayton, OH 45414

Get Directions

Gessel & Associates

Since 1999, Gessel & Associates Insurance Agency has been providing comprehensive insurance solutions to customers in Dayton, London, Columbus, and Cincinnati. Specializing in auto insurance, the family-run, independent agency offers a range of coverage options, such as medical payments, bodily injury liability, property damage, and uninsured-underinsured motorist coverage. Furthermore, their experienced agents are available to assist clients in the process of filing claims, ensuring they receive the optimal balance of coverage, price, and claims service.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://gesselins.com/

Phone: +1 740-852-7725

Full Address: 27 E 4th St, London, OH 43140

Get Directions

Royal Crest Agency

Royal Crest Agency is an independent insurance agency offering car insurance plans to the residents of Cincinnati. They represent multiple insurance providers and their policies provide financial protection for both the policyholders and other persons in case of an accident. Their comprehensive coverage extends to fire or theft damage and they also cover medical and repair expenses. Clients can easily request an insurance quote online using their online tool.

Rating: 4.9

Website : http://www.royalcrestagency.com/

Phone: +1 937-667-9359

Full Address: 29 W Main St, Tipp City, OH 45371

Get Directions

Mitchell Insurance Agency – Plain City

Established in 1993 by founder Robb Mitchell, Mitchell Insurance Agency – Plain City is the largest Ohio partner of Erie Insurance. The agency offers a variety of personal insurance plans in Dayton, and is renowned for its independent agents who build proposals with multiple insurance carriers, such as Progressive, Travelers, and MetLife. They assist car owners in understanding and assessing financial risks and obtaining adequate coverages for losses due to collisions, injury liabilities, or natural disasters.

Rating: 4.9

Website : http://www.insurance-mitchell.com/

Phone: +1 614-873-1088

Full Address: 7450 Industrial Pkwy, Plain City, OH 43064

Get Directions

Matulka Insurance Agency

For over 20 years, Matulka Insurance Agency has been providing exceptional service to individuals, families, and businesses in and around the Dayton metro area. Their independent insurance agents help clients find the right auto insurance policy that will best suit their needs, offering a range of basic coverage options such as liability, comprehensive, and collision coverage. Motorcycle and recreational vehicle policies are also available.

Rating: 4.7

Website : https://www.matulkainsurance.com/

Phone: +1 937-781-0011

Full Address: 2262 County Line Rd, Beavercreek, OH 45430

Get Directions

American Casualty Insurance, LLC.

At American Casualty Insurance, LLC, drivers in and around Dayton can find the perfect auto insurance plan for their needs. Our independent insurance company offers a variety of carriers to choose from, as well as personal injury protection (also known as no-fault coverage), which covers funeral, replacement, medical, and rehabilitation expenses. Our knowledgeable team will help you select the right policy and provide education on the various insurance options available. Our ultimate goal is to ensure you have the plan that best suits your needs.

Rating: nan

Website : https://americancasualtynow.com/

Phone: +1 937-607-5914

Full Address: 4550 Salem Ave #B, Dayton, OH 45416

Get Directions

Jay Hines Insurance Agency

At Jay Hines Insurance Agency, Dayton-area drivers can find auto insurance that meets their needs. Veteran-owned and operated, the company’s proprietor, Jay A. Hines, works with multiple insurance carriers to secure protection plans at competitive rates. Jay Hines Insurance Agency also offers policies for antique cars, motorcycles, and motorhomes. With a wide range of insurance products, the agency ensures drivers have the coverage they need to stay safe on the road.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.jayhinesagency.com/

Phone: +1 937-738-7480

Full Address: 1281 Pepper Ln, Marysville, OH 43040

Get Directions

Popular Posts