8 Best Local Car Insurance Agencies in Newark, NJ


Are you a driver in Newark, NJ looking for the best car insurance coverage? Look no further! In this blog post, we’ll go over 8 of the top local car insurance agencies in Newark, NJ. We’ll go over the different coverage options, pricing, and more to help you find the best policy for you and your vehicle. Get ready to find the perfect car insurance policy for your needs!

Massey Insurance Agency

For over 45 years, Ramelle Massey, a member of the Newark Regional Business Partnership, has been leading Massey Insurance Agency – a women-owned independent company – in providing clients in Newark with car insurance policies that protect them from financial responsibilities for property damage and injuries. These policies may also help reimburse losses from theft, vandalism, and fire. In addition, the agency offers risk management solutions for homes, condominiums, vacant dwellings, and recreational vehicles, as well as general liability and workers’ compensation assistance for businesses.

Rating: 4.6

Website : https://www.masseyagency.com/

Phone: +1 973-926-6300

Full Address: 46 Lyons Ave, Newark, NJ 07112

Get Directions

Arbor Insurance Services LLC

Arbor Insurance Services LLC is an independent agency that serves individuals, families, and businesses in the Newark metro and surrounding areas. They specialize in automobile insurance policies, which can include various coverages such as bodily injury and property damage liability, collision, comprehensive, personal injury protection, and uninsured motorist coverage. In addition, the firm offers a wide range of other insurance plans, including homeowners’, renters’, umbrella, and workers’ compensation insurance. Arbor Insurance Services is an authorized representative of American Strategic Insurance and Universal North America.

Rating: nan

Website : https://myarborinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 866-987-1453

Full Address: 251 Montgomery St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003

Get Directions


Since 1999, ESTIR has been providing Newark and its surrounding communities with a wide range of car insurance coverage options. Collision, comprehensive, bodily injury, property damage, personal injury protection, and uninsured/underinsured motorists are all available. The agency also offers commercial auto insurance plans for businesses that own or operate multiple vehicles. ESTIR works with multiple insurance carriers, such as American Modern, Plymouth Rock Assurance, and The Philadelphia Contributionship.

Rating: 4.2

Website : https://www.estirinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 973-481-5300

Full Address: 652 Bloomfield Ave, Bloomfield, NJ 07003

Get Directions

Choice International Agency

Grazyna Torbus, a veteran of the industry since 1986, leads Choice International Agency, an independent firm providing a range of services to individuals, families, and businesses in and around Newark. The agency offers custom protection plans for drivers, antique car owners, and motorcycle riders, as well as policies for home and condominium owners. Backed by partner carriers such as Zurich, National General, Mercury, Travelers, and MetLife, Choice International Agency is proud to offer services in Polish.

Rating: 3.7

Website : https://www.choiceagencyins.com/

Phone: +1 973-773-7448

Full Address: 348 Main Ave, Wallington, NJ 07057

Get Directions

Otterstedt Insurance Agency

Otterstedt is an acclaimed auto insurance provider with eight locations in New Jersey, including Newark. They facilitate customers in finding competitive rates through collaboration with various insurance companies, offering a wide range of coverage options like collision, comprehensive damage, bodily injury and medical payments, uninsured motorists coverage, property damage, personal injury no-fault protection and rental car reimbursement. This company has been honored by Insurance Journal as one of the Top 5 Insurance Agencies in the country.

Rating: nan

Website : http://otterstedt.com

Phone: +1 908-273-2422

Full Address: 291 Morris Ave, Summit, NJ 07901

Get Directions

SAS Insurance Agency, Inc

Established in 1965, SAS Insurance Agency, Inc. has grown from a one-man operation to a full-service agency providing risk management solutions for more than 2,000 families in the Newark area. They offer auto insurance, including liability coverage and medical expenses for injuries sustained in accidents, as well as reimbursements for theft losses. Some of the carriers they represent include MetLife, UPC Insurance, and Providence Mutual.

Rating: 3.9

Website : https://www.sasinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 732-355-3903

Full Address: 233 Kearny Ave, Kearny, NJ 07032

Get Directions

Geisenheimer Insurance Agency

Founded in 1979 by Alan Geisenheimer, the Geisenheimer Insurance Agency is dedicated to providing reliable personal and commercial automobile insurance for Saddle Brook, New Jersey customers. Specializing in helping local small businesses, the Agency offers professional guidance on the eligibility, exclusions and limits of insuring vehicles and drivers. For personal car insurance, the Agency assists New Jersey drivers in understanding the state’s legal requirements and provides a range of insurance carriers to best suit their needs and budget.

Rating: 3.5

Website : http://tgiainsurance.com

Phone: +1 201-794-7200

Full Address: 299 Market St Suite 200, Saddle Brook, NJ 07663

Get Directions

The Four Corners Agency

For over three years, The Four Corners Agency has been providing individuals, families, and businesses from Newark and the surrounding areas with reliable insurance policies. They offer a variety of auto insurance coverages, such as collision, comprehensive, and liability coverage. Additionally, they provide homeowners’, renters’, and condo insurance, as well as commercial auto, commercial property, and workers’ compensation insurance plans. With a commitment to quality service and customer satisfaction, The Four Corners Agency is an independent insurance agency that can be trusted.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.thefourcornersagency.com/

Phone: +1 551-221-2880

Full Address: 497 Broadway Suite 9, Bayonne, NJ 07002

Get Directions

Popular Posts