8 Best Pet Insurance Companies in Columbus, OH


If you’re a pet owner in Columbus, OH, and have been searching for the best pet insurance companies in the area, you’ve come to the right place! We’ve done our research and found eight top pet insurance companies that offer reliable coverage, competitive rates, and exceptional customer service. Whether you’re looking for basic accident and illness coverage, or something more comprehensive, you’ll find a plan that fits your needs and budget. Read on to learn more about the eight best pet insurance companies in Columbus, OH.

Dostal & Kirk

Since its merger in 29, Dostal & Kirk has been a top provider of pet insurance policies for Columbus pet owners. It sources its policies from a selection of national carriers and then deploys local adjusters to promptly attend to claims, allowing pet owners to address their veterinary needs efficiently. In addition to pet insurance, Dostal & Kirk also provides farm insurance policies, such as an equine insurance protection plan, and other personal and business lines of insurance. Furthermore, the company offers financial planning and wealth management services. Jeffrey A. Kirk, the founder of the company, has been in the insurance industry since 1981 and holds Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter and Certified Insurance Counselor designations.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.dostalkirk.com/

Phone: +1 614-389-4246

Full Address: 9783 Fairway Dr A, Powell, OH 43065

Get Directions

Wiles Insurance Agency

Established in 24, Wiles Insurance Agency provides clients in Columbus and its surrounding areas with a variety of personalized services. From pet insurance policies to cover veterinary treatment and medication costs to auto, flood, homeowners’, individual life, renters’, and personal umbrella plans, the firm represents different carriers to meet the needs of its customers. Moreover, it offers business packages tailored to the needs of apartment building owners’, contractors’, commercial property, and general liability insurance.

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://wilesinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 614-536-0370

Full Address: 348 Granville St suite e, Gahanna, OH 43230

Get Directions

Penn Summit Insurance Agency LLC

For over 14 years, Penn Summit Insurance Agency LLC has been providing services to clients in Columbus, Ohio. Specializing in pet insurance policies, the agency offers coverage options for veterinary bills in the event of illnesses, accidents, and other medical needs. It provides customers with the ability to choose from a variety of carriers for their pet insurance. Not only that, but Penn Summit also offers insurance solutions for both personal and business needs. Representing a range of companies, including Amerisafe, Acuity Insurance, and Progressive, the independent agency is an active member of the Fayette Chamber of Commerce.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://pennsummit.net/

Phone: +1 724-329-0386

Full Address: 2989 National Pike, Chalkhill, PA 15421

Get Directions

Sara Smucker

Based in Westerville, Ohio, Sara Smucker is an American Family Insurance agent, providing a variety of products such as pet insurance. This coverage includes hospitalization, surgery, emergency and specialty care, as well as prescription drugs to treat pet illnesses and injuries. Smucker and her team build policies that are tailored to their clients’ needs and assist them during the claims process. Serving individuals and families in the Columbus metro and surrounding areas, she is also licensed in Arizona, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, and Oregon.

Rating: 4.7

Website : https://www.amfam.com/agents/ohio/westerville/Sara-Smucker

Phone: +1 614-890-5005

Full Address: 918 Eastwind Dr, Westerville, OH 43081

Get Directions

Sokol Eisenberg Insurance

Sokol Eisenberg Insurance is dedicated to providing individuals, families, and businesses in the Columbus metro and surrounding areas with peace of mind. Offering pet insurance policies for animal protection, as well as auto, disability, health, home, life, and long-term care insurance plans, the agency also provides protection plans for businesses and employee benefits programs. As a member of the Ohio Insurance Agents Association, Sokol Eisenberg Insurance is led by owner Adam Eisenberg, who has an impressive 25 years of experience in the industry.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.sokoleisenberginsurance.com/

Phone: +1 614-235-1111

Full Address: 1620 E Broad St #103, Columbus, OH 43203

Get Directions

Byrd Insurance

Tom Byrd, the owner of Byrd Insurance in Hilliard, has been in the insurance industry since 1998 and helps Columbus residents find pet protection policies. He collaborates with Firefly to provide paw parents with comprehensive coverage options like Pets Best policies from Progressive and dog grooming policies from Foremost. These policies cover accidents, hereditary conditions, prescriptions, as well as other features such as dental cleaning and vaccines.

Rating: nan

Website : https://www.byrdinsurancegroup.com/

Phone: +1 614-870-5141

Full Address: 5212 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228

Get Directions

Mike Mathers

Mike Mathers, a State Farm Insurance agent serving Columbus and its surrounding communities, has over two years of experience in both leadership and customer service. He offers customizable pet insurance policies tailored to the medical needs of different breeds of cats and dogs. His team works with Trupanion to provide coverage options which include illnesses, injuries, medications, breed-specific conditions, treatments, and procedures. Furthermore, Mathers provides notary public services and is a supporter of the Worthington Chamber of Commerce.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://mikemathersinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 614-846-7411

Full Address: 1000 High St h, Worthington, OH 43085

Get Directions

Adam Deel

Adam Deel has been in the insurance industry for over 10 years, offering a wide selection of policies to the people of Columbus and its surrounding metros. His products include homeowners’, renters’, condo, property, auto, business, pet, life, health, hospital income, Medicare supplement, annuities, mutual funds, banking, and surety and fidelity bonds.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://deelsf.com/

Phone: +1 614-451-3800

Full Address: 1288 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43220

Get Directions

Popular Posts