8 Best Renter’s Insurance Companies in Columbus, OH


Are you a renter in Columbus, OH looking for the best insurance options to protect your belongings? Look no further, because we’ve got you covered! In this blog post, we’ll be discussing the 8 best renter’s insurance companies in Columbus, OH. We’ll discuss the different coverage options, customer service and more, so you can make the best decision for your needs. Read on to learn more about the best renter’s insurance companies in Columbus, OH!


Headquartered in Columbus, Branch is an insurance company that makes it easy to purchase home, auto, renters, and umbrella insurance with only a few pieces of information. Clients can bundle multiple policies together, such as home & auto or renters & auto, for additional savings, and the company also offers coverage for recreational vehicles, motorcycles, and boats. It provides clients with extra options like protection for home-sharing, ride-sharing, and valuables, and its stress-free switching online service helps clients cancel their existing policies from another provider. What’s more, the Branch team has an average of 14 years of insurance experience, and it is a member of the Columbus Chamber of Commerce.

Rating: 4.4

Website : https://branch.com/

Phone: +1 855-441-7033

Full Address: 20 E Broad St Ste. 1200, Columbus, OH 43215

Get Directions


Insura, a locally-owned independent insurance agency, offers a variety of services to clients in Columbus and its surrounding areas. These services include renter’s, condo, and home insurance policies as well as motorhome, recreational, auto, and umbrella insurance. Renters’ insurance policies offered by Insura include personal property, liability, and other additional coverages, designed to protect clients from potential damages or accidents caused by disasters or man-made threats. What sets Insura apart is its commitment to providing individualized plans tailored to meet each client’s specific needs, capacities, and changing situations.

Rating: 4.3

Website : https://insura4you.com/

Phone: +1 614-221-7007

Full Address: 1180 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222

Get Directions

Guardian Insurance Solutions

For five years, Joe Justus of Guardian Insurance Solutions has been providing Columbus renters with insurance, banking, and wealth management solutions. His renters’ policy covers various items, including clothing, collectibles, computer equipment, entertainment systems, gaming consoles, and furniture, which are protected against theft or disaster. In addition, tenants are also protected against liability for accidental damage to property and injury to guests. Guardian Insurance Solutions offers products from a variety of companies, including American Modern, Encompass, Foremost, Liberty Mutual, and The Hartford.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.guardianinsuranceohio.com/

Phone: +1 614-451-7100

Full Address: 4694 Cemetery Rd PMB 406, Hilliard, OH 43026

Get Directions

J. R. Scott Insurance Agency, Inc.

Julie E. Schatz, with over a decade of experience, has recently acquired and is now managing J. R. Scott Insurance Agency, Inc., which serves individuals and businesses in Columbus. The independent agency provides clients with insurance products such as home, renters’, auto, and motorcycle insurance, allowing them to protect themselves financially from unexpected life events and have peace of mind. Agents at the agency conduct personalized assessments to identify clients’ insurance needs and offer business insurance plans, including general liability and commercial auto insurance.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://jrscottinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 614-263-9699

Full Address: 3620 N High St Suite 203, Columbus, OH 43214

Get Directions

McGlothin Insurance & Financial

With more than a decade of experience, McGlothin Insurance & Financial offers comprehensive insurance solutions in Columbus. Its range of services covers personal lines, such as renters’ insurance and renters’ liability coverage, as well as life, homeowners’, business, and auto insurance plans. The agency works with leading insurance providers, including Safeco Insurance, State Auto Insurance Corporation, and Stillwater Insurance Group. In addition, President Brock McGlothin leads the firm in its fundraising campaigns for local charities every six months.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://iwantprotected.com/

Phone: +1 614-274-0112

Full Address: 6059 Frantz Rd Suite 106, Dublin, OH 43017

Get Directions

Lynn Insurance

Lynn Insurance, based in Columbus, OH, is an agency that caters to property tenants required to have insurance policies. It initially began as a captive agency, but the management realized they could offer better service to their clients with multiple options. They now partner with various carriers, allowing their agents to compare plans like renters’ insurance from providers such as Erie, Foremost, Progressive and Travelers, explaining the coverage features to help shoppers in their selection. Not only that, but they also offer other policies such as home, auto, life and RV.

Rating: 4.5

Website : https://www.lynngroup.biz/

Phone: +1 614-779-0092

Full Address: 751 N Wilson Rd, Columbus, OH 43204

Get Directions

The Griffin Lantz Insurance Agency, LLC

and have since expanded their reach to serve clients across the state.

Griffin Lantz Insurance Agency, LLC, was founded in 24 by Bart Griffin and Josh Lantz, and is based in Dublin, with services extending to the Columbus metro. Specializing in property and liability insurance, they provide comprehensive renters’ policies for apartment residents and rental unit owners covering personal belongings and assets from damage, theft, and vandalism. These policies also include coverage for the renter and family members against bodily injury and liability claims, and any related litigation, up to the limits selected by the client. Over the years, the company has grown and now serves clients throughout the state.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://griffinlantzinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 614-799-1217

Full Address: 6047 Frantz Rd #206, Dublin, OH 43017

Get Directions

Augustine Insurance Agency

Since 1955, Augustine Insurance Agency has been providing Columbus-area individuals and families with risk management services. This family-owned and family-operated business offers insurance plans to protect renters from financial loss due to property damage, theft of personal belongings, and additional living expenses due to a covered event, as well as legal responsibility for injured guests within the property. Additionally, its agents provide coverage for health, auto, life, and pet insurance policies.

Rating: 4.7

Website : https://www.augustineinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 614-267-1973

Full Address: 3851 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214

Get Directions

Popular Posts