8 Best Renter’s Insurance Companies in Kansas City, MO


Are you a renter in Kansas City, MO looking for the best renter’s insurance? Look no further! We’ve taken the guess work out of the equation and compiled a list of the 8 best renter’s insurance companies in Kansas City, MO. No more searching through hundreds of companies to find the one that’s right for you. We’ve done the research and are here to bring you the best of the best. Read on to discover the top 8 renter’s insurance companies in Kansas City, MO and the benefits they have to offer.


Founded in 215 by Lockton Companies, Mylo is a Kansas City-based independent insurance agency led by Chief Executive Officer and founder David Embry. With over 2 years of experience in the industry, Embry’s agency offers renters’ insurance to clients, providing coverage for their personal belongings and injuries to their guests in the event of disasters such as theft, vandalism, or fire. Mylo has also partnered with LegalZoom, Insperity, and Bold Penguin to better serve its customers.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://choosemylo.com/

Phone: +1 844-863-5950

Full Address: 8880 Ward Pkwy #200, Kansas City, MO 64114

Get Directions

Matthew Rich

Matthew Rich, a risk management specialist affiliated with Farmers Insurance, has been a resident of Kansas City for many years. He specializes in providing renters’ insurance policies which include medical payments, liability coverage, and personal property protection. Rich also offers insurance to condominium, home, recreational vehicle, and motorcycle owners. Moreover, he provides a full range of products for businesses, including general liability, business property, and commercial auto insurance.

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://agents.farmers.com/mo/kansas-city/matthew-rich

Phone: +1 816-479-4747

Full Address: 5752 N Broadway, Kansas City, MO 64118

Get Directions

Alexa Barkley

Alexa Barkley of State Farm has been serving the Kansas City area with renters’ insurance for years, offering both standard and customized plans to protect tenants and their property. With Alexa and her team’s membership in the State Farm Honor Club since their first year, and their commitment to the local animal shelter, Unleashed, you can trust that you’ll receive comprehensive coverage for specialized emergencies such as natural disasters and vandalism.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://alexaquotemyinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 816-678-0931

Full Address: 1300 E 104th St Suite 210, Kansas City, MO 64131

Get Directions

Briarcliff Insurance Group

For over two decades, Briarcliff Insurance Group has been a premier provider of insurance products in Kansas and Missouri. As an independent agency, it can shop around for clients to find the best coverage and rates from multiple companies, offering renters’, homeowners’, auto, life, and umbrella insurance. The experienced staff is also available to help with claims filing. Briarcliff Insurance Group provides comprehensive coverage and service for all of your insurance needs.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.briarcliffinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 816-759-2133

Full Address: 1508 NW Vivion Rd Ste 300, Kansas City, MO 64118

Get Directions

Bargain Insurance Connection

Since its founding in 27, Bargain Insurance Connection, a local insurance agency based in Kansas City, has been providing a wide range of personal and commercial insurance products from its partner carriers. These products include renters’ insurance, which generally safeguards personal possessions inside the tenant property from fire, theft, and other damages. Liability insurance and extra living costs are also covered, providing protection for personal injury of a guest or emergency evacuation.

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://www.bic-agent.com/renters/

Phone: +1 816-453-7722

Full Address: 2635 NE Vivion Rd, Kansas City, MO 64119

Get Directions

Northland Independent Insurance Group

For over two decades, Leon Van Berkum, founder of the Northland Independent Insurance Group, has been providing financial protection to clients in Kansas City. The firm offers renters’ insurance to cover theft and injuries occurring within the residence, as well as policies for condos, homes, autos, boats, motorcycles, and RVs, for incidents not covered by the landlords’ insurance policy.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://northlandindependentgroup.com/

Phone: +1 816-587-1826

Full Address: 5575 NW Barry Rd, Kansas City, MO 64154

Get Directions

Traders Insurance

Traders Insurance, located in Kansas City and its surrounding communities, specializes in helping customers protect themselves from unexpected expenses. Their Renters Value Plan insurance covers rental homes that have been damaged by fire, storm, or robbed, and also covers hospital bills for guests injured on the client’s property. In addition, the company offers a variety of auto insurance plans. Many of their past customers have expressed satisfaction with Traders Insurance, citing their helpfulness in educating them about their insurance options.

Rating: 4.3

Website : https://tradersauto.com/

Phone: +1 800-369-0369

Full Address: 9300 Troost Ave, Kansas City, MO 64131

Get Directions

Safeway Insurance Agency

For over 2 years, Safeway Insurance Agency has been providing residents of Kansas City with a variety of insurance products and services. From auto and home insurance, to SR-22 and watercraft coverage, the company offers a range of insurance options to individuals and businesses. Their team of experienced insurance agents are dedicated to helping clients choose the appropriate policy that fits their coverage needs. Whether it’s personal or commercial insurance, Safeway Insurance Agency has the coverage you need.

Rating: 4.3

Website : https://www.safewayagency.com/

Phone: +1 816-931-1222

Full Address: 3406 Broadway Blvd Suite A, Kansas City, MO 64111

Get Directions

Popular Posts