8 Best Renter’s Insurance Companies in Pittsburgh, PA


Are you a renter in the Pittsburgh, PA area looking to protect your belongings with renters insurance? You’ve come to the right place! In this blog post, we’ll be outlining the 8 best renters insurance companies in Pittsburgh. From customer service to coverage options, we’ll walk you through the features of each company to help you find the perfect fit. So let’s get started!

Casper Insurance Agency

Since 1955, Casper Insurance Agency has been offering a wide range of products to customers in Pittsburgh. These include renters’, homeowners’, condo, and auto insurance, with the renters’ policy particularly providing coverage for the insured and their belongings while renting, as well as liability in the case of injury on the premises. The agency also provides business insurance, featuring commercial auto, general liability, and workers’ compensation coverage, and works with several well-known carriers, including Erie, Progressive, Travelers, and Grange.

Rating: 4.5

Website : https://www.casperinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 412-486-9200

Full Address: 611 Mt Royal Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15223

Get Directions

James L. Smith Insurance

At James L. Smith Insurance, we provide independent risk management solutions for individuals and families in the Pittsburgh area. Our renters’ insurance policies cover possessions against theft, vandalism, and damage from fire, lightning, explosion, windstorm, and water, and also protect the renter from additional costs of temporarily living away due to disasters. We work with multiple insurance companies, such as Liberty Mutual and Encompass, to provide comprehensive coverage for automobiles, homes, recreational vehicles, life, and business.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.insurancepittsburgh.co/

Phone: +1 412-531-3111

Full Address: 304 Cochran Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15228

Get Directions

Sharp Insurance

Sharp Insurance Agency is the perfect choice for customers in Pittsburgh and its surrounding areas looking for insurance. The agency offers renters’ insurance policies that will protect the client and their possessions in case of injury, destruction, or loss. In addition, they provide coverage for snowmobile, motorcycle, collector car, mobile home, and valuable items insurance. As an independent company, Sharp Insurance Agency is partnered with several carriers, including Erie Insurance, Bristol West Insurance Group, and Dairyland.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.sharpinsagency.com/

Phone: +1 412-207-9047

Full Address: 2811 Brownsville Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15227

Get Directions

Cusumano Insurance Agency, Inc.

Since its inception in 1958, Cusumano Insurance Agency, Inc. has proudly been serving Pittsburgh as a family-run business. Offering renters’, home, life, health, and business insurance, this Trusted Choice agency is dedicated to providing customers with the best coverage to meet their needs. With carriers like Chubb, Cumberland Mutual, Encompass, Foremost, and Berkshire Hathaway, Cusumano Insurance Agency, Inc. has the resources to help protect clients and their belongings. Its renters’ insurance policy specifically offers protection against burglaries, fires, and natural disasters. Additionally, the agency is a member of the Independent Agents & Brokers of America (IA&B).

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://cusumanoinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 412-655-4432

Full Address: 178 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236

Get Directions

HHM Insurors Benefits

For more than 7 years, HHM Insurors Benefits has been providing personal and commercial insurance solutions to clients in the Pittsburgh metro and its surrounding areas. With more than 24 years of collective experience in the industry, the agency’s team of agents specializes in home insurance policies, including renters’ insurance. This policy offers protection from damages caused by fire, theft, and vandalism to tenants living in apartments, condominiums, and dorms. Additionally, HHM Insurors Benefits provides an optional liability coverage to its renters’ policy.

Rating: 4.0

Website : https://www.hhminsurance.com/

Phone: +1 412-893-2500

Full Address: 500 Commerce Dr #100, Coraopolis, PA 15108

Get Directions

Stalwart Insurance

Residents of Pittsburgh and its surrounding areas can count on Stalwart Insurance for their renters’ coverage. The company provides umbrella policies to safeguard against liabilities due to accidents, floods, and theft, as well as life, RV, and automobile plans. Stalwart Insurance is partnered with leading carriers such as Universal Property, Rockingham Insurance, and the Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company to deliver indemnity products.

Rating: 4.8

Website : https://www.stalwartpersonallines.com/

Phone: +1 412-677-2312

Full Address: 2550 Boyce Plaza Rd, Pittsburgh, PA 15241

Get Directions

Brown Insurance Agency

Since 1998, Brown Insurance Agency has been providing individuals and families in Pittsburgh with renters’ insurance policies. Its coverages offer financial protection from unexpected occurrences such as fire, theft, and personal injury. With access to policies from a number of carriers including National General, Universal Property, and Plymouth Rock Assurance, the agency ensures policyholders receive the best coverage available. In addition, Brown Insurance Agency also offers insurance solutions for houses, condos, and mobile homes.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.brown4insurance.com/

Phone: +1 412-681-7114

Full Address: Office Service, 5001 Baum Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15213

Get Directions

McIlrath Insurance Agency

Founded by Robert McIlrath in 1945, McIlrath Insurance Agency is a Pittsburgh-based independent insurance agency that has been providing clients with a wide range of insurance services for over 75 years. The agency was passed down to his son, Mac McIlrath, in 1974. McIlrath Insurance Agency offers comprehensive home insurance policies for homeowners and renters, which provide investment protection against damages resulting from floods, poor maintenance, and household pets. Additionally, their policies cover damages to the property and any liability for injuries caused to other people or properties.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.mcilrathinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 412-882-9000

Full Address: 4601 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA 15236

Get Directions

Popular Posts