8 Best Renter’s Insurance Companies in Toledo, OH


If you’re a renter in the Toledo area, you know how important it is to have the right insurance coverage. With so many options available, it can be hard to know which one is best for you. To make things easier, we’ve done the research and narrowed it down to the 8 best renter’s insurance companies in Toledo, OH. We’ll tell you all about the different types of coverage they offer, their customer service ratings, and more. Keep reading to learn more and find the right policy for you.

DJ Gluckle Insurance & Financial Agency

DJ Gluckle Insurance & Financial Agency is a locally owned and operated business serving the Toledo community and its surrounding areas. As an independent agency, they partner with more than 3 carriers to provide their clients with a wide range of insurance and financial products, such as home insurance coverages including renters’, homeowners liability, condo, landlords, and scheduled property insurance, as well as auto, life, farm, business, and retirement insurance. Their experienced team is dedicated to guiding clients through the entire insurance process.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://gluckleinsuranceagency.com/

Phone: +1 419-887-1363

Full Address: 4213 N Holland Sylvania Rd, Toledo, OH 43623

Get Directions

Anderson/Miller Insurance Agency

Anderson-Miller Insurance Agency is a full-service company that provides a wide array of insurance plans to customers in and around Toledo. Their renters insurance plans come from top national carriers such as Foremost and Gemworth. They offer customized policies that include coverage for property damage, medical liability, temporary housing, loss of possessions, and even specialized items like furs and firearms. In addition to renters insurance, the agency offers life and business insurance.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.andersonmillerinsurance.com/

Phone: +1 419-882-1770

Full Address: 4149 N Holland Sylvania Rd Suite 3, Toledo, OH 43623

Get Directions

Dave Bly

Dave Bly, a State Farm insurance agent and resident of Toledo, offers services to individuals and businesses in Hoover and the surrounding areas. He specializes in home and property insurance plans such as rental property, condominium, manufactured home, farm and ranch, and renters’ insurance policies. Dave is also equipped to provide business insurance services, like business owners’ and contractors’ policies, commercial auto insurance, and liability umbrella plans. He has been a State Farm agent since 1981 and comes from a family of State Farm agents.

Rating: 4.5

Website : https://davebly.com/

Phone: +1 419-474-9672

Full Address: 2416 W Laskey Rd, Toledo, OH 43613

Get Directions

Midwest Insurance Network

Midwest Insurance Network is a go-to resource for Toledo residents seeking renters’ insurance. Their policies offer protection for personal items and property owners from liability, reimbursement for loss of use, coverage of living expenses, and safeguards for landlords. In addition to serving Toledo, the company is licensed to provide services in Michigan and Florida. Lindsey Romstadt serves as office manager and Jake Shank is the principal agent.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://midwest-insure.com/contact/northwood-oh-insurance/

Phone: +1 419-720-5825

Full Address: 3310 Woodville Rd d, Northwood, OH 43619

Get Directions

Auto Plus Insurance Agency

Since 1993, Teresa Marshall has been co-managing the AutoPlus Insurance Agency that offers protection to renters and homeowners against loss or damage to their belongings and personal liability from mishaps on their property. This company also provides similar products for automobiles, recreational vehicles, and motorcycles, backed by carriers such as Safeco, Hagerty, and Progressive. AutoPlus Insurance Agency is open to inquiries from clients in Toledo communities and other neighboring metros.

Rating: 4.9

Website : https://www.autoplustoledo.com/

Phone: +1 419-697-0041

Full Address: 860 Ansonia St, Oregon, OH 43616

Get Directions

Insurance Solutions

For over 15 years, Insurance Solutions has been providing the Toledo metro and its surrounding areas with personalized business and personal insurance policies. They offer renters’ insurance plans for those leasing their residences, such as tenants of apartments and condos. This policy guarantees coverage for personal property, liability, and additional living expenses in the event of a loss. Additionally, they can provide security policies for boats, RVs, and antique cars.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://www.insurancesolutionsnwo.com/

Phone: +1 419-794-7456

Full Address: 2321 River Rd, Maumee, OH 43537

Get Directions

Compass Insurance Services

Compass Insurance Services, established in 21, is a Toledo-based insurance agency that provides a wide range of personal and commercial insurance solutions. Among these offerings is renters’ insurance, which safeguards against losses or damages caused by burglaries, fires, and water damage. In the event that the rented unit becomes uninhabitable due to these occurrences, some policies may even provide compensation for alternative accommodation and liability coverage.

Rating: 5.0

Website : https://compassinsurancetoledo.com/

Phone: +1 419-885-7283

Full Address: 3011 Tremainsville Rd, Toledo, OH 43613

Get Directions

Ardena Williams

Williams, an agent with Farmers Insurance, provides a range of insurance products to individuals, families, and businesses in the Toledo metro and the surrounding areas, including renters’ insurance, auto, condominium, home, life, motorcycle, and recreational insurance plans. She also assists with shopping for other insurance products, such as pet, personal umbrella, commercial property, general liability, and workers’ compensation insurance. This coverage helps protect customers in the event of fires, natural disasters, and other unfortunate occurrences.

Rating: 4.6

Website : https://agents.farmers.com/oh/toledo/ardena-williams

Phone: +1 419-897-9028

Full Address: 2325 S Reynolds Rd, Toledo, OH 43614

Get Directions

Popular Posts